How to End a Story with a Shiver: Crafting Haunting Conclusions

A well-crafted ending lingers, slipping into readers' minds and leaving them haunted long after they’ve turned the last page. This Halloween, let’s explore how to end a story in a way that truly chills. From horror to thrillers, the conclusion isn’t just about wrapping things up—it’s about delivering a final punch that keeps readers thinking, reeling, and even a bit scared. Here’s how to achieve that spine-tingling effect with examples from some of the best haunting endings in literature.

The Ambiguous Ending: Leaving Questions Unanswered

One of the most effective ways to end a story hauntingly is through ambiguity. When you leave certain details open to interpretation, readers are left wondering and imagining what could happen next, creating a lasting sense of unease.

Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House

The story concludes with Eleanor's fate uncertain. Has she been overtaken by the supernatural forces of Hill House, or has she succumbed to her own mental instability? Jackson leaves the readers in suspense, which reinforces the eerie, psychological tone of the story. A successful ambiguous ending keeps readers on edge, long after they’ve put the book down.

Craft Tip: Instead of neatly resolving every plotline, leave room for lingering questions that give readers a sense that the horror may not be fully over.

The Last-Minute Twist: One Final Shock

Ending a story with a surprise twist can amplify the horror, making readers rethink everything they thought they knew. The key is to embed the twist subtly throughout the narrative so that it feels both inevitable and shocking.

Stephen King’s Pet Sematary

Just when the protagonist thinks he’s found a twisted sense of closure, the story takes a horrifying turn with a knock at the door—suggesting that the consequences of tampering with life and death have come full circle. This chilling twist makes readers feel as if they’re standing beside him, holding their breath.

Craft Tip: Drop subtle hints and foreshadowing throughout your story, then unveil the twist at the last possible moment. This not only shocks but also encourages readers to revisit the story, finding clues they may have missed.

The Descent into Darkness: A Bleak, Unsettling Ending

Sometimes, leaving readers with a sense of dread is more powerful than any twist or ambiguous ending. A dark conclusion that shows the protagonist’s fall or a never-ending horror can resonate deeply, haunting readers with its realism.

Cormac McCarthy’s The Road

Though not a horror novel in the traditional sense, The Road ends on a haunting note. The bleak journey of survival in a desolate world suggests that any semblance of hope is fleeting. This grim ending lingers, staying with readers as they reflect on the fragility of human nature.

Craft Tip: Craft your ending to reflect the overall tone of your story. If it’s bleak, avoid an artificial happy ending. Instead, show the impact of the protagonist’s choices and create an atmosphere that leaves readers unsettled.

The Unreliable Narrator: A Distorted Reality

Endings with an unreliable narrator can leave readers questioning the truth of everything that’s transpired, which is both unsettling and thought-provoking. This technique works particularly well in psychological thrillers and horror stories, where readers are already on edge.

Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl

As the story draws to a close, readers are left grappling with the twisted dynamic between Amy and Nick. The dual unreliable narrators cast doubt on what’s real and what isn’t, leaving an aftertaste of discomfort that’s perfect for a psychological thriller.

Craft Tip: Use your narrator’s perspective to alter readers’ perceptions of the story’s conclusion, keeping them on edge by distorting reality in subtle, eerie ways.

The Cyclical Ending: Horror Comes Full Circle

Ending your story where it began can suggest that the horror is destined to repeat, trapping characters in a cycle from which they can never escape. This technique reinforces the idea of inevitable doom, which can leave readers feeling helpless and disturbed.

Henry James’s The Turn of the Screw

The chilling revelation at the end suggests that the spirits haunting the manor will continue to influence future inhabitants. This cyclical ending hints at an unstoppable force, creating a shiver-inducing conclusion.

Craft Tip: If your story features an antagonist or entity that can never be fully defeated, ending with a return to the beginning can emphasize the ongoing nature of the horror. This sense of continuity is unsettling, making readers feel as if they’ve barely escaped its grasp.

The Last Line: Ending on a Striking Note

Sometimes, all it takes is a single, haunting sentence to leave readers with a shiver. A well-chosen final line can be just as impactful as any twist or cliffhanger, delivering a sense of finality while leaving the reader’s imagination to run wild.

Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca

The final line reveals that Manderley has been destroyed, yet its memory looms over the protagonist’s life. This simple revelation is packed with foreboding and brings the story full circle without spelling out every detail.

Craft Tip: Spend time crafting a last line that resonates with the tone of your story and evokes an emotion in readers. A haunting line can evoke a shiver without explicit horror, leaving a subtle mark.

Making It Stick: A Haunting Ending That Lasts

A haunting ending isn’t about cheap thrills; it’s about psychological resonance and emotional depth. By leaving certain threads untied, adding a surprising twist, or reinforcing themes of inevitability, you can craft an ending that lingers long after the story ends. The key is to let your ending speak to the core of your story’s horror, making readers carry the weight of your story even as they try to shake it off. Happy haunting!

Ready to Take Your Novel to the Next Level?

If you're eager to push past your fears and write the novel you've always dreamed of, check out The Complete Novelist’s Kit—a collection of 30 practical guides designed to help you from concept to completion. With tools to keep you motivated, organized, and focused, The Complete Novelist’s Kit will give you everything you need to overcome your fears and finish your novel.

Click here to check it out

Let’s get your story out into the world!