How to Write Characters Who Lie: Crafting Deception in Fiction

Lying is a fundamental part of human interaction, and it can be an incredibly useful tool in fiction for creating tension, conflict, and complex character dynamics. Writing characters who lie convincingly requires attention to detail, psychological insight, and an understanding of the narrative implications of deception. Here are some tips to help you craft characters who lie effectively in your stories.

Flesh Out the Motivation Behind the Lie

Understanding why a character lies is crucial for creating depth and authenticity in their behavior. Every lie a character tells should be grounded in their personality, backstory, and current situation, making it an extension of who they are rather than a mere plot device. This motivation not only drives the lie itself but also influences how the character feels and behaves before, during, and after the lie is told.

For instance, consider a character who lies out of fear. This fear might stem from a past trauma, an abusive relationship, or a rigid societal structure that punishes non-conformity. Such a character may exhibit physical signs of anxiety when lying—sweating, trembling, avoiding eye contact, or stumbling over their words. They might also overcompensate in other areas of their life to manage the stress that their dishonesty creates. For example, they could become obsessively neat or overly agreeable, trying to exert control in areas where they can to balance the lack of control they feel when lying.

On the other hand, a character who lies out of a desire for power or manipulation operates very differently. These individuals often lie strategically, using deception as a tool to achieve specific goals. Their lies are more calculated, and they are likely to remain composed under pressure, carefully choosing their words to maintain the upper hand. Such characters might enjoy the thrill of deception, taking pleasure in outsmarting others or watching the ripple effects of their lies unfold. They might also view honesty as a weakness, something that can be exploited in others but should be avoided themselves.

For example, in Shakespeare's Othello, Iago's lies are deeply rooted in his desire for power and control. His manipulations are carefully crafted to provoke jealousy and suspicion, and he remains calm and collected as he orchestrates the downfall of those around him. His lies align perfectly with his cunning and strategic personality, making them believable and terrifyingly effective.

Alternatively, in George Orwell’s 1984, Winston Smith lies to protect his forbidden thoughts and emotions from the Party. His lies are driven by fear—fear of being caught, tortured, or "vaporized." This fear manifests in his paranoid behavior, his constant vigilance, and his deep internal conflict as he struggles to maintain his sanity in a world where even thinking the wrong thing is a crime.

By anchoring lies in the character's core traits and motivations, writers can create complex, multifaceted characters whose dishonesty feels authentic and integral to the story. This approach not only enriches character development but also enhances the overall narrative, allowing readers to engage more deeply with the moral and psychological dimensions of the story.

Show the Consequences of Lying

Lies, once set in motion, often have far-reaching consequences that extend beyond the immediate situation. They rarely exist in isolation; instead, they ripple outward, affecting not only the liar but also those around them. When a character tells a lie, it can create a web of deception that complicates relationships, alters the character's standing in the world, and begins to erode their sense of self. The pressure to maintain the lie, coupled with the fear of being discovered, can add significant tension and complexity to the narrative.

One of the most significant impacts of a lie is on the character’s relationships. Trust is a foundational element in any relationship, and lies can quickly undermine it. As the lie persists, the character might become more distant or secretive, creating suspicion and doubt in those around them. For example, a character who lies about their past might constantly worry about being exposed, leading them to push others away to avoid getting too close. This can create a sense of isolation and loneliness, as the character sacrifices genuine connections in favor of maintaining the lie.

In addition to affecting relationships, lies can also alter a character’s standing in the world. A character who builds their reputation or success on a lie risks everything if the truth comes out. The lie might provide short-term benefits, such as career advancement or social status, but the potential for exposure creates a ticking time bomb. As the story progresses, the character may go to greater lengths to protect their deception, leading to increasingly risky or unethical behavior. This can result in a downward spiral, where the character's attempts to cover up the lie only dig them deeper into trouble.

The internal struggle of maintaining a lie is another critical aspect to explore. The character may experience guilt, shame, or anxiety, as they are constantly reminded of the deception they are upholding. This internal conflict can lead to a fractured sense of self, as the character grapples with the disparity between their true identity and the persona they present to the world. The longer the lie persists, the more difficult it becomes for the character to reconcile these two aspects of their identity, leading to a crisis of conscience or a complete unraveling of their moral compass.

The tension between maintaining the lie and the fear of being caught can drive much of the story’s conflict. This tension can manifest in various ways, such as the character’s increasing paranoia, the growing suspicion of those around them, or the escalating consequences of the lie. As the story progresses, the lie may begin to unravel, forcing the character to confront the truth. The revelation of the lie can serve as a pivotal moment in the story, leading to a dramatic shift in the character’s relationships, their standing in the world, and their internal sense of self.

Ultimately, the fallout from the lie can be as compelling as the lie itself. Whether the character is forced to confess, is caught in their deception, or decides to come clean on their own, the consequences of the lie should be fully explored. How do the character’s relationships change? How does the character’s view of themselves evolve? What new challenges arise as a result of the truth being revealed? By digging into these questions, you can create a rich and layered narrative that resonates with readers and provides a deeper understanding of the character’s journey.

Use Body Language and Subtext

When writing dialogue, it's essential to remember that the spoken words are just one layer of communication. Characters often say things that don’t fully align with their true thoughts or feelings. This discrepancy can add depth to the dialogue and make the interaction more engaging for the reader. The key to writing effective dialogue lies in the subtle use of body language, facial expressions, and subtext to reveal the character's true intentions or emotions, even when their words suggest otherwise.

For instance, consider a character who is lying about their whereabouts on a particular night. While they might verbally provide a detailed account of where they were, their non-verbal cues could tell a different story. They might avoid eye contact, their voice could falter, or they might fidget nervously. These physical signs can clue the reader in on the fact that the character is lying, even if the other characters in the scene believe the lie. This creates dramatic irony, where the reader knows more than the other characters, heightening the tension in the scene.

On the other hand, a more skilled liar might exhibit entirely different behaviors. A character who is adept at deception might maintain steady eye contact, speak with confidence, and use charm to make their lies more believable. This kind of character might not show any of the typical signs of lying, making it harder for both the reader and the other characters to discern the truth. However, even skilled liars can have tells—subtle slips in their behavior or inconsistencies in their story that can hint at the underlying truth.

The gap between what a character says and what they truly mean can be a powerful tool in storytelling. Through careful use of subtext, you can layer meaning into your dialogue. A character might say something innocuous on the surface, but their tone of voice or choice of words might suggest something entirely different. For example, a character might tell someone, "I'm happy for you," but the way they say it—perhaps with a forced smile or a slight edge in their voice—can reveal jealousy or bitterness. This use of subtext allows the reader to pick up on the true emotions at play, even if the words themselves don’t convey them directly.

This technique also allows you to explore complex character dynamics and relationships. When characters are not entirely truthful with each other, it can create tension and conflict that drives the story forward. The reader, aware of the underlying dishonesty, becomes more invested in the outcome, wondering when and how the truth will be revealed. By playing with the contrast between a character’s words and their non-verbal cues, you can craft dialogue that is rich with meaning and full of potential for conflict and drama.

In summary, when writing dialogue, it's crucial to consider not just what your characters say, but how they say it. Use body language, facial expressions, and subtext to convey the truth behind the words. Whether your character is a nervous liar who can't hide their discomfort or a confident deceiver who seems entirely trustworthy, these layers of communication can add depth to your story and engage your readers on a deeper level.

Vary the Types of Lies

Not all lies carry the same weight or consequences. Some lies are minor, perhaps told to avoid minor inconveniences or to spare someone's feelings. On the other hand, some lies are grand deceptions that can have serious, far-reaching implications, affecting the course of the story and the relationships between characters. When writing a character who lies, it's important to use a variety of lies throughout the narrative to create a dynamic and unpredictable storyline.

A character might begin by telling a small, seemingly harmless lie. For example, they might lie about being late to a meeting, blaming traffic when, in reality, they overslept. This small lie might seem insignificant, but it can set the stage for a pattern of deceit. As the story progresses, this character might find themselves in more complex situations where telling the truth becomes increasingly difficult. The lies may start to escalate—what began as a small fib could evolve into a significant falsehood that entangles the character in a web of deceit.

This escalation can build tension and suspense in your story. The reader, aware of the initial lie, might anticipate the consequences as the character digs themselves deeper into their deception. The accumulation of lies can lead to a tipping point where the character can no longer keep up the façade. This moment of reckoning is often a critical turning point in the narrative, forcing the character to confront the reality they've been avoiding.

Incorporating a variety of lies into your story adds complexity and intrigue, making your characters more multifaceted and your plot more engaging. Whether your character lies out of fear, selfishness, or a misguided sense of protection, these deceptions can serve as the backbone of a compelling narrative. By allowing lies to evolve and escalate, you can create tension and suspense that keeps the reader hooked, all while exploring the moral and emotional consequences of deceit.

Explore the Psychological Impact

Lying can take a psychological toll on your characters. Explore how the act of lying affects them mentally and emotionally. Do they feel guilt, or are they indifferent? Does the lie change how they see themselves or how others see them? A character who lies might begin to feel isolated, paranoid, or trapped in their own web of deceit. Alternatively, they might become more emboldened and reckless as they continue to lie. This internal conflict can drive character development and make the story more compelling.

Ready to Take Your Novel to the Next Level?

If you're eager to push past your fears and write the novel you've always dreamed of, check out The Complete Novelist’s Kit—a collection of 30 practical guides designed to help you from concept to completion. With tools to keep you motivated, organized, and focused, The Complete Novelist’s Kit will give you everything you need to overcome your fears and finish your novel.

Click here to check it out

Let’s get your story out into the world!